Should You Pay "All Cash" For Your Home? Pros & Cons

An "All Cash" situation does happen quite often.person, you should be able to buy a house of this
For whatever personal reasons, some peoplevalue that you could rent for at least $100.00
desire to own their home free and clear. Themore than it takes to make the monthly
psychology of cash, or course, gives the buyer apayments which would be $1,200 profit per year.
negotiating advantage in the acquisition process;In addition to that, you would have the same
but like all other situations, it does have its Pros$9,000 appreciation or 6% of the $150,000 value
and Cons. Let's take a look at some of these.of the house. so, the appreciation plus the $1,200
PRO - Benefits of Owning Your Home Free andfrom the rental would get you $10,200 per year.
Clear:You deduct the $8,400 interest you pay on the
1. It does give people a sense of security. While$120,000 loan and find that you earned $1,800.
you can't put a dollar figure on this benefit, it is athat first year on the rental house. In addition,
motivating factor.your equity increase (loan balance reduction)
2. It eliminates the necessity of making paymentswould be $1,219 making your total earnings for
on a mortgage. This, of course, means that therethe first year $3,619.
is no reverse cash flow in owning the home withRemember, you only used $30,000 of the
the exception of maintenance, insurance and$160,000 that remained of your original capital.
taxes.Let's assume that you could buy five of these
These benefits have many side effects, but theyrental houses with $30,000 down in addition to the
all seem to basically relate to security and cashhome you bought for yourself. If you purchased
flow. Because it's people that really count, thefive of these rental homes similar to the example,
above mentioned benefits may outweigh all of theeach of them earning you $3,619 per year, you
economical benefits that point to a direction otherwould receive $18,095 in earnings per year from
than owning one's home free and clear.your rental houses. In addition to that, you had
CON - Basic Leverage in Owning Real Estate That$6,360 earnings from your own home that you
is Not Free and Clear:purchased which would deliver then a total of
In looking at this side of the picture, we are going$24,455 in earnings per year on the $190,000
to compare to owning a house which is free &cash investment, or a return of 12.2% per year
clear of encumbrances. For purposes of our-vs- 2% you had on purchasing one home for
comparison let's assume that you are going toALL CASH. * And you have $10,000 cash left
buy a $200,000 home in which to live. And let'sover for reserve.
assume that you have the $200,000 and can payIn addition, you would have other benefits, such
ALL CASH - $200,000.as tax shelter on your investments, which can be
Let's also assume that we have appreciationexpressed in dollars. We are not attempting here
taking place in your area which is a constant 6%to analyze this situation. Our purpose is to show
per year. So, your home would be worththe use of leverage in its simplest form. This is an
$212,000 at the end of one year.EXAMPLE of the use of the money in other than
If instead of buying the home for "All Cash", let'sa cash sale. The above, of course, is merely a
say you purchase it with 20% down or $40,000cursory exploration of the benefits of leverage
and you owe $160,000 on a 5% mortgage. Theversus the ALL CASH purchase. The benefits in
interest would be 8,000 for the first year. If youreach person's mind would dictate their choice. This
house increased in value $12,000 in the first year,comparison merely develops both sides of the
your earnings for the first year would be $4,000.question for your perusal.
If you paid $8,000 in interest and you houseThis is not to be considered to be investment
appreciated $12,000, the difference is $4,000. Inadvice. Any person considering investing should
addition, your equity (the Loan less Loancommunicate with experienced investment advice
Reduction) increase the first year would befrom competent people in their own geographical
$2,360. Your total earnings the first year wouldarea. Some of the information for this article was
be $6,360.excerpted from Robert W. Steele's book "50
Remember, of the original $200,000 in capital, youways to Acquire Real Estate".
have only used $40,000. You can now takeThese posts are the opinion of the author who is
another $30,000 and buy a home valued atnot engaged in rendering legal, accounting, or
$150,000 for rental purposes. Now you wouldinvestment advice. If such advice is required or
owe $120,000 at 7% (probably higher than 5%desired, the services of competent professional
for income property), which is $8,400 in interestpersons should be sought.
per year. If you are a reasonably good business